Transportation & Logistics

We are independent consultants providing expertise in system selection, best practice and business process improvement for transportation and warehousing industries.

Distribution ERP Software Selection - Interviews

Requirements

Some of the requirements that differentiate systems are:

Warehouse Management:

  • Rate management
  • Quotations
  • Products are customer specific
  • Customer portal
  • Storage and handling charges
  • Accessorial activity charges
  • Rates can vary by customer/consignee/product/carrier
  • Restrictions by pallet type, height, trailer temperature…

Transportation Management:

  • Rate management
  • Quotations
  • Agent and customer portals
  • Multiple routes with multiple stops
  • Driver management
  • Dispatching
  • Truck load optimization

Systems

  • Tier 1
  • Tier 2
  • Tier 3
  Acumatica Microsoft Dynamics 365 Finance & Operations NetSuite Oracle Cloud ERP Pronto Xi SAP S/4 HANA TECSYS
Product Information              
System Acumatica Microsoft Dynamics 365 Finance & Operations NetSuite Oracle Cloud ERP Pronto Xi SAP S/4 HANA TECSYS
Vendor Acumatica Microsoft Dynamics 365 NetSuite Oracle Cloud ERP Pronto Xi SAP S/4HANA TECSYS
Description Acumatica was born in the cloud, built to meet the ever-evolving needs of midmarket companies and their customers.
  • Easily integrate the tools and systems you already use
  • Improve efficiency with our intuitive, award-winning UI
  • Empower collaboration with modern, cross-module workflows
  • Access your data from any device
  • Personalize your instance in a low-code / no-code environment
  • Scale users and resources up or down as needed
Dynamics 365 launched in 2016 when Microsoft brought together Dynamics AX, its ERP application and the Dynamics CRM application. Microsoft was one of the first to make a move an offer an integrated solution. Given the dynamic nature of business and the likelihood of unique situations, it is becoming more and more important for software/solution providers to introduce applications that cater to the changing trends. Dynamics 365 is a comprehensive suite of services enabling all in one solutions so that you don’t have to pick and choose from the plethora of options available. Microsoft Dynamics 365 can be used for:
  • Bringing your business together as a cohesive unit by connecting people, processes, and data across many applications, including Microsoft Dynamics 365, Office 365, LinkedIn, and Azure.
  • Making smarter decisions with built-in AI, analytics, and guided action suggestions.
  • Adapting the application to your needs rather than changing your business methodology. You can integrate most applications with existing systems or even customize with Microsoft Power Platform.
  • Modernize your approach by incorporating AI, mixed reality, social, and mobile capabilities for progressive business innovation.
  • Full-featured financials, CRM, inventory, project management and ecommerce software--all in a single system
  • Real-time visibility across your entire business operation
  • On-demand software infrastructure dramatically lowers maintenance and license fees
  • Real-time dashboards for all your key employees
  • Anywhere, anytime access to the information you need.
Oracle Cloud ERP is a complete, modern, cloud ERP suite that provides advanced capabilities, such as AI to automate the manual processes that slow them down, analytics to react to market shifts in real time, and automatic updates to stay current and gain a competitive advantage. With headquarters and our Development Centre located in Melbourne, we have support offices and consultants based across Australia, as well as a global network of Resellers and Solution Partners. Pronto Xi, our flagship Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) solution helps you to monitor and control every aspect of your business, from top floor to shop floor. Gain insights about what’s making you money and where your best opportunities lie – from improving productivity and customer service to inventory accuracy and more. Specialised business units within Pronto Software have the expertise to assist you with pivotal technology – Digital Transformation with Pronto Woven, Cloud and Hosting services with Pronto Cloud and Business Intelligence solutions with Pronto iQ. When you choose Pronto Software, you gain a team with decades of industry experience and a single-minded dedication to helping our customers achieve their growth and revenue goals. That’s why for more than 40 years, over 1,700 Australian and global organisations, across a wide range of industries, have trusted us to simplify their most complex challenges. As the market leader in enterprise application software, SAP helps companies of all sizes and in all industries run better by redefining ERP and creating networks of intelligent enterprises that provide transparency, resiliency, and sustainability across supply chains. SAP's end-to-end suite of applications and services enables customers to operate profitably, adapt continuously, and make a difference worldwide. Serving healthcare, distribution and converging commerce industries, and spanning multiple complex, regulated and high-volume markets, Tecsys delivers warehouse management, distribution and transportation management, supply management at point of use, and retail order management, as well as complete financial management and analytics solutions.
Website https://www.acumatica.com/ https://dynamics.microsoft.com https://www.netsuite.com/ https://www.oracle.com/erp/ https://www.pronto.net/ https://www.sap.com/
Primary Tier 2 1 2 1 2 1 2
Industries              
Apparel No No Yes No No Yes No
Construction Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes No
Field Services No No Yes No No No No
Financial Services No Yes Yes Yes No Yes No
Food & Beverage No Yes Yes Yes No Yes No
Hospitality No Yes Yes Yes No Yes No
Manufacturing Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No
Nonprofit No No No No No No No
Professional Services No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No
Retail & ECommerce Yes Yes Certified Yes Yes Yes No
Transportation & Logistics Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Wholesale Distribution Yes Yes Certified Yes Yes Yes Yes
Applications              
Accounting (General Ledger, Financial Reporting, Accounts Receivable, Accounts Payable, Budgeting and Cash Management) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Asset Management No No Yes No No Yes No
CPQ (Configure Price Quote) Yes No No No No Yes No
CRM Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Distribution (Order Processing, Purchasing and Inventory) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No
E-commerce Yes Yes No Yes No Yes No
Field Services - Dispatching & Scheduling Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes No
Field Services - Mobile Field Management Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No
Human Resource Management Yes No Yes Yes No Yes Yes
Manufacturing - Quality Control Yes No No Yes Yes Yes No
Manufacturing - Scheduling Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes No
Manufacturing - Shop Floor Control No Yes Yes Yes No Yes No
MRP Yes No No Yes No Yes No
Payroll Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes No
Point of Sale No No No Yes No Yes Yes
Product Lifecycle Management Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes No
Professional Services - Scheduling No No No Yes No Yes No
Professional Services - Timesheets No No No No No No No
Professional Services – WIP Management No No No No No No No
Project Management No No No No No No No
Transportation Management No No No No No No No
Warehouse Management No No No No No No No
Developer Information              
Number of customers - all products
Number of customers - this product
Technology              
% of application that is web based (just need a browser on workstation)
On premise, cloud or hybrid On Premise On Premise On Premise On Premise On Premise On Premise On Premise
Private or Public Cloud Private Private Private Private Private Private Private
Multi-tenant architecture Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Generic Requirements              
Customization/Configuration              
Without changing source code In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release
User-defined fields
  • Can define values/dropdowns for fields
  • Used in report selection and ordering
  • Used in workflow
In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release
User defined screens
  • Change fields to required, optional or invisible for standard and user-defined field
In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release
Multiple Companies              
Share inventory across companies In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release
Share customers and suppliers across companies In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release
Automate balancing of transactions across legal entities In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release
PO of 1 company automatically generates the sales order in another company In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release
Multiple Currencies              
Maintain source and home currency amount for each transaction In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release
Date effective currency exchange rates In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release
Work Flow              
Can apply an approval process to any transaction such as a journal entry or any master file such as a supplier or inventory item In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release
Can generate alerts/escalation if something expected is late or reminders In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release
Configurable approvals or alerts without needing programming In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release
Mobility              
Optimized for Android and iPhone In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release
Offline mode and synch when internet connected In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release
Sales tax compliance              
Canadian sales tax compliance In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release
US sales tax compliance In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release
Reporting/Business Intelligence              
Reporting              
Industry standard reporting tool and can change existing reports or add new ones In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release
Ad-hoc reporting (don’t need a programmer) with filtering, sorting and summarizing options In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release
Dashboards              
Based on real time updates from all transactions In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release
Role specific In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release
Configurable dashboards - don't need to be a programmer to create or change dashboard In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release
Analytics              
Drag and drop dimensions In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release
Visualization/graphic representation of data In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release In Current Release

Testimonials

We found Michael very detailed and in a nice way a "pain in the ass", he kept on building on the requirements more and more, willing to extract more at times for clarification. Challenges he had, the transportation industry has very limited opportunities for product selection. He could filter the vendors well through his methodology. His approach to get to a smaller pool was a definite benefit, not only me but our IT Department accepted his approach. That's an accomplishment in our world, since our mother company has a lot of project experience, but his methodology was embraced and will be used in the future.
Anonymous
180 Systems is very thorough and gets down to the nuts and bolts of the business to get a thorough understanding of what our user requirements are and understanding of process flows. They ask a lot of good questions about why things are done a certain way and are very good at probing users to discover their issues and formulate requirements that a new system needs to address. 180 Systems gets people relaxed and engaged quickly, focuses on the issues and keeps things moving along. For companies that don't have someone on board that has ERP selection experience, 180 Systems is a great help. They get beyond the "dog and pony show" of vendors, cutting through to the core functionality that does or does not meet your requirements. I'd recommend 180 Systems to any medium sized company where IT resources are scarce, even to larger companies where IT departments don't have the experience with what S/W is out there, whereas 180 Systems has it all and been there done that.
George Czubak, CFORemco